Carhartt Vs Patagonia (The Definitive Guide)

By Unlock Wilderness

10th April 2023

Are you a workwear enthusiast torn between the rugged durability of Carhartt and the eco-friendly ethos of Patagonia? Well, the debate over Carhartt vs Patagonia has been raging on for years, with both brands having their own unique strengths and weaknesses.

But fear not, because in this article, we'll take a deep dive into the key differences and similarities between these two iconic brands, helping you make an informed choice about your workwear wardrobe.

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Carhartt Vs Patagonia

Quality and Durability

When it comes to tough workwear that can withstand the elements, Carhartt has been the go-to brand for many professionals for decades. Their reputation for quality and durability is second to none in the workwear industry, and it's easy to see why. Carhartt products are built to last with heavy-duty materials and reinforced stitching, making them a reliable choice for even the toughest jobs.

That being said, Patagonia has also made a name for themselves in the world of high-quality, durable apparel. While their focus on sustainability and ethical manufacturing sets them apart from Carhartt, it doesn't mean they sacrifice quality in any way. In fact, Patagonia products are well-known for lasting a long time, even with regular use.

So, if you're someone who prioritizes sustainability and ethical manufacturing in your clothing choices, Patagonia may be the way to go. But if you're looking for workwear that can withstand tough conditions and last for years, you can't go wrong with Carhartt. Regardless of which brand you choose, one thing is for certain - quality and durability are key factors in both of their products.

Style and Functionality

When it comes to choosing between Carhartt and Patagonia, one of the biggest considerations is usually style and functionality. It's important to consider what type of work environment you're in and what kind of clothing best suits your everyday needs.

Carhartt is known for its classic workwear designs, with a focus on ruggedness that's perfect for industrial and manual labor jobs. Though the brand has been around for over 100 years, their styles have remained relatively unchanged, cementing their place as one of the most trusted names in workwear fashion.

On the other hand, Patagonia offers a wider range of designs that can often be considered trendy and versatile. Their clothing is aimed more towards outdoor recreational activities and combines both performance and style.

Depending on your style preferences and work needs, you may favor one brand over the other. If you prefer the timeless and reliable workwear aesthetic, Carhartt will surely be a great choice for you. But if you're looking for more modern and versatile pieces of clothing that can serve you well in different situations, Patagonia may be just what you need.

In the end, it's all a matter of personal preference and what individual requirements are most important to you. Whether you choose Carhartt, Patagonia or any other brand, the most important thing is to find something that suits you and enhances your performance in your everyday work and activities.

Pricing and Value

When it comes to deciding between Carhartt and Patagonia, one of the factors that many people consider is pricing and value. It's true that Carhartt's prices are usually lower than Patagonia's, but that doesn't necessarily mean that one is a better value than the other.

Both Carhartt and Patagonia offer a range of products at different price points, so it's important to think about what you're looking for and what your budget is. Are you willing to spend more for a higher-end product that may last longer and perform better? Or are you content with a more affordable option that gets the job done?

When it comes to value, there are a few things to consider. First, quality. While Carhartt may have lower prices, their products are still known for their durability and ruggedness. Patagonia, on the other hand, is known for their high-quality outdoor gear that is made to last even in the toughest conditions.

Next, consider the purpose of the product. Are you looking for workwear that can withstand the wear and tear of a job site? Or are you in need of outdoor gear that will keep you warm and dry in extreme weather conditions? Each brand has their strengths, so it's important to look for products that are tailored to your specific needs.

Finally, think about style. While value and quality are important, let's face it - we all want to look good in our clothes. Carhartt's signature look is rugged and utilitarian, while Patagonia is known for their sleek and modern designs. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and what style fits you best.

In the end, whether you choose Carhartt or Patagonia comes down to what you're looking for in terms of quality, durability, style, and price point. Both brands offer great products that are designed to meet a variety of needs, so it's up to you to decide which one is the best value for your money.

Brand Values and Sustainability

When it comes to choosing between Carhartt and Patagonia, it's important to consider what values and principles are most important to you. While both brands offer quality apparel, they approach their manufacturing processes and materials sourcing differently.

Patagonia has made sustainability a core value, and their efforts towards it are evident throughout their supply chain. They use recycled materials wherever possible, and they have implemented fair trade and ethical labor practices in all of their factories. Patagonia has even pledged 1% of their sales to support nonprofit organizations that focus on causes such as environmental protection and social justice.

Carhartt, on the other hand, is primarily focused on creating durable clothing that lasts. While they don't tout sustainability as a core value, they do use high-quality materials, which means that you'll get more wear out of garments, keeping them out of the landfill for longer.

When deciding between these two brands, consider what matters most to you. Do you value environmental sustainability and ethical manufacturing? Or are you more concerned with buying clothing that is designed to last? If you prioritize sustainability, look no further than Patagonia. Their commitment to using recycled materials, implementing fair labor practices, and supporting nonprofit organizations make them a true industry leader.

But if you're after clothing that will stand the test of time, Carhartt might be more your style. Their sturdy, rugged materials are sure to hold up against daily wear and tear better than most.

Ultimately, the choice between Carhartt and Patagonia should be based on your personal values and priorities. No matter which brand you choose, rest assured that both offer high-quality apparel that you can feel good about wearing.

Carhartt Vs Patagonia Work Jackets

When it comes to work jackets, Carhartt and Patagonia are two of the most well-known and respected brands on the market. While both offer a wide range of options for all your workwear needs, there are some notable differences between the brands.

Let's start by looking at the Carhartt Full Swing Insulated Traditional Coat. This jacket is made from durable duck material and features stretch across the shoulders and arms for free movement. It has 80-gram 3M™ Thinsulate™ insulation for warmth and a Corduroy-trimmed collar and internal rib-knit storm cuffs for added protection. The Full Swing design allows you to move freely, while the ample pockets provide plenty of storage. Carhartt is known for its rugged and durable workwear, and the Full Swing Insulated Traditional Coat is no exception.

Now let's consider the Patagonia Iron Forge Hemp® Canvas Ranch Jacket. This coat is crafted from the brand's hardworking Iron Forge Hemp™ canvas, which is more abrasion-resistant than conventional cotton duck canvas and requires no break-in period. It features a blend of industrial hemp, recycled polyester, and organic cotton material, with a 100% recycled polyester taffeta lining and 100-g Thermogreen® insulation. The jacket is designed for tough tasks in cold conditions and features a roster of pockets for tools and tech. It has heavy-duty front zippers with an oversized metal pull, a bi-swing back for freedom of movement, double-reinforced elbows for abrasion resistance, and rib-knit internal cuffs to lock out the cold.

So, which brand is best for you? It ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific job requirements. If you're in need of heavy-duty and durable workwear, Carhartt is a great choice. The Full Swing Insulated Traditional Coat is one of the brand's most popular work jackets and offers ample storage and ultimate flexibility for getting the job done.

If you're looking for highly sustainable and durable workwear with a focus on environmental responsibility, Patagonia's offerings are the way to go. The Iron Forge Hemp® Canvas Ranch Jacket is just one example of the brand's commitment to sustainable materials and practices. It's a reliable and functional jacket that's perfect for outdoor work or tough tasks in cold conditions.

Ultimately, no matter which brand you choose, you can trust that you're getting a high-quality product that's tailored specifically for the demands of the job.

Full Swing Insulated Traditional Coat by Carhartt

SHOP ❤ Check price on carhartt.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Move like you mean it with this work jacket.

What makes it special? This coat combines classic style with modern design, resulting in a jacket that lets you move freely without compromising warmth or durability. The 12-ounce ring-spun washed cotton duck material feels broken-in from day one, while the 80-gram 3M™ Thinsulate™ insulation keeps you toasty without adding bulk. The Full Swing design allows for stretch across the shoulders and free arm movement, so you won't feel confined or hindered while on the job. The Corduroy-trimmed collar and internal rib-knit storm cuffs are thoughtful touches that offer an extra layer of protection against the elements. The two-way center front zipper with snap and hook-and-loop secure storm flap is a practical feature that will keep your belongings safe and secure. Plus, with two bellowed chest pockets and two large bellowed lower-front pockets, you'll have all the space you need to stash your essentials. Carhartt-strong triple-stitched main seams and reinforcement on the pockets add durability to the equation. And the two inside pockets (with hook-and-loop closure and zipper) provide even more secure storage for your valuables. If you're looking for a reliable and functional piece of workwear, the Full Swing Insulated Traditional Coat is a solid choice.

Find the best price on Carhartt

Iron Forge Hemp® Canvas Ranch Jacket by Patagonia

SHOP ❤ Check price on patagonia.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Tough, durable and functional work jacket for cold conditions.

What makes it special? This jacket is made from their hardworking Iron Forge Hemp™ canvas, which is 25% more abrasion-resistant than conventional cotton duck canvas and requires no break-in period. The body of the jacket is made from a blend of industrial hemp, recycled polyester, and organic cotton, with a 100% recycled polyester taffeta lining and 100-g Thermogreen® insulation. What sets this work jacket apart from others on the market is its exceptional durability and design. It features heavy-duty front zippers with an oversized metal pull for easy operation with gloves, while the placket has snap closures to protect finished surfaces from the zipper. The bi-swing back allows for excellent freedom of movement through the upper body, while the double-reinforced elbows add abrasion resistance and durability. The rib-knit internal cuffs lock out the cold, ensuring that you stay warm no matter the conditions. But what about storage? This jacket doesn't disappoint in that department either. It boasts a roster of pockets for tools and tech, including two pleated snap-closure chest pockets for expandable storage (with a pencil opening at the top of each flap), two lower handwarmer pockets with fleece lining, and a zippered internal security pocket on the left chest for stashing your phone, wallet, keys, and other valuables.

Find the best price on Patagonia

Carhartt Vs Patagonia Work Overalls

When it comes to work overalls, Carhartt and Patagonia are two of the most respected brands in the industry. Comparing the two brands offerings can help you decide which one to go for.

Carhartt's Relaxed Fit Duck Bib Overall is an excellent representative of the brand's offerings. Made from heavyweight cotton duck with triple-stitched main seams, these overalls are incredibly durable and dependable. With adjustable elastic suspenders, ample pockets, and double-layer knees, they offer plenty of features that make them ideal for challenging work environments.

Patagonia's Iron Forge Hemp Canvas Bib Overalls are another great option. Made from a blend of industrial hemp, recycled polyester, and organic cotton, these overalls are remarkably abrasion-resistant and perfect for outdoor work. With adjustable suspenders and waist, along with a range of useful utility pockets, they provide excellent functionality and durability.

Compared to Carhartt's offering, the Patagonia overalls are more environmentally friendly and made of more sustainable materials. They also feature doubled knees with bottom openings that accommodate kneepads, which is a noteworthy feature also available in Carhartt's.

Ultimately, deciding between Carhartt and Patagonia comes down to personal preference. Those who prioritize durability and a traditional rugged look may prefer Carhartt, while those seeking eco-friendliness and innovation may find Patagonia a better fit. Both brands offer excellent options, so it's up to you to decide which one is right for your needs.

Relaxed Fit Duck Bib Overall by Carhartt

SHOP ❤ Check price on carhartt.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Durable and comfortable work overalls for hardworking individuals.

What makes it special? These bib overalls are not only comfortable to wear all day, but they're also durable enough to withstand the toughest job sites. One of the most impressive features of these bib overalls is the stretch piecing at the waist which provides increased range of motion, making it easier to move around and bend down when needed. The bibs also come equipped with multiple pockets that are perfect for holding all your essential tools and gadgets. The multi-compartment bib pocket with zip closure is particularly handy for keeping your phone, wallet, and keys safe and secure. Furthermore, the double-layer knees with openings for adding knee pads and cleaning out debris provide unmatched protection while the reinforced 360-degree kick panels around cuffs add durability to the bibs. These bibs offer the perfect combination of comfort, durability, and functionality, making them the perfect choice for any hardworking individual.

Find the best price on Carhartt

Iron Forge Hemp® Canvas Bib Overalls by Patagonia

SHOP ❤ Check price on patagonia.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Durable and versatile work overalls for tough outdoor work.

What makes it special? Made from a blend of industrial hemp, recycled polyester and organic cotton, these overalls are incredibly abrasion-resistant and perfect for tough outdoor work. Compared to the work overalls offered by Carhartt, the Iron Forge Hemp Canvas Bib Overalls are 25% more abrasion-resistant, giving you unparalleled durability and protection on your toughest jobs. These overalls feature adjustable suspenders and waist, ensuring a customizable fit for all body types and layer configurations. The bib's zipper pocket and outer snap pocket, along with the two front drop-in pockets and seat pockets, provide ample storage for your tools and tech. One standout feature of these overalls is the doubled knees with bottom openings that accommodate kneepads and allow easy cleanout. This is a significant advantage over other work overalls, making it easier for you to work safely and effectively while protecting your knees.

Find the best price on Patagonia

Carhartt Vs Patagonia Work Pants

Both Carhartt and Patagonia offer a range of work pants, but the two reviewed products – Carhartt's Rugged Flex and Patagonia's Iron Forge Hemp Canvas – highlight some key differences between the brands.

On the one hand, Carhartt is known for its classic workwear, and the Rugged Flex pants embody that spirit. They are built for durability and practicality, with double-layer knees, reinforced pockets, and knee pad compatibility. Plus, the Rugged Flex technology provides added stretch for ease of movement. Overall, Carhartt offers a range of practical and rugged work pants that are well-suited to a variety of jobs.

On the other hand, Patagonia's work pants, such as the Iron Forge Hemp Canvas pants, emphasize sustainability and innovation. Made from a blend of industrial hemp, recycled polyester, and organic cotton, these pants are incredibly durable and abrasion-resistant, as well as eco-friendly. Patagonia is also known for its Fair Trade Certified™ sewn products, including the Iron Forge Hemp Canvas pants. Furthermore, the Iron Forge Hemp Canvas pants offer a gusseted crotch for added flexibility and contoured waistband for increased strength and carrying capacity.

Ultimately, the decision between Carhartt and Patagonia work pants comes down to personal preference and priorities. If you value classic workwear that is rugged and practical, Carhartt is a great choice. If you care about sustainability and innovation, and want work pants that are both durable and eco-friendly, Patagonia is the way to go. Both brands offer high-quality work pants that are well-suited to a range of jobs, so the choice is yours.

Rugged Flex Work Pants by Carhartt

SHOP ❤ Check price on carhartt.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Maximum durability and convenience for daily work.

What makes it special? These are purpose-built pants that prioritize durability and convenience. The double-front design adds to the longevity of the pants, while the knee pad compatibility ensures that you can work on your knees without worrying about discomfort or damage to your clothing. The midweight canvas blend, with the perfect amount of stretch, makes it easy for you to move around comfortably while working. The pants even have extra pockets, a secure right thigh phone pocket, and a left thigh utility pocket for your knife, making them even more practical for your daily work. The strong seams, double-layer knees, and reinforced front slash pocket ensure that these pants can withstand tough working conditions. Meanwhile, the comfortable fit through the seat and thigh and the straight leg, with the added stretch of Rugged Flex technology, allow for ease of movement. These pants even have a gusseted crotch for even more stretch between the legs. They're versatile, comfortable, and built to withstand heavy-duty wear and tear.

Find the best price on Carhartt

Iron Forge Hemp® Canvas Double Knee Pants by Patagonia

SHOP ❤ Check price on patagonia.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Unmatched durability and comfort for the toughest jobs.

What makes it special? These heavy-duty work pants are made from Patagonia's innovative 12.9-ounce Iron Forge Hemp™ canvas, which is 25% more abrasion resistant than conventional cotton duck canvas and needs no break-in period. Plus, the gusseted crotch allows for freedom of movement on the job. But the durability doesn't stop there. These work pants also feature work-specific reinforcements such as a contoured waistband with seven belt loops for increased strength and carrying capacity, a sturdy zip fly with metal-button closure, and doubled knees for added durability in high-contact areas. In terms of storage, these pants have you covered with deep front pockets that can hold hand tools and gussets for an everyday-carry knife or tape measure. The deep drop-in back pockets also keep hand tools handy and create a double-fabric seat for added abrasion resistance. With a 32-inch inseam and the ability to accommodate kneepads, these work pants are the perfect addition to any job site. They provide unmatched durability and comfort for even the toughest of jobs.

Find the best price on Patagonia

Final Verdict

So there you have it – the ultimate showdown between Carhartt and Patagonia workwear. From their origins to their materials and styles, both brands are certainly worth considering for your workwear needs. Whether you seek warmth and durability or eco-friendliness and innovation, these two top contenders have got you covered.

But in the end, which one should you choose? Well, it largely depends on your personal preferences, your specific job requirements, and your budget. Some may prefer Carhartt's classic, rugged workwear style and extensive range of options, while others may opt for Patagonia's more versatile, sustainable offerings.

Ultimately, both Carhartt and Patagonia have built strong reputations for their quality and reliability over the years, and either one would make a fine choice for your workwear needs. So whichever brand you go with, you can feel confident that you're investing in gear that will last you through many hard days on the job site. Happy shopping!